Choose Big Cartel if you need
- Integration with PayPal, Google Shopping or Zapier. We haven't found them on Square Online's website.
At a glance
- Both have a free plan.
- Big Cartel's lowest paid plan is Platinum at $15 per month, as of October 23, 2026.
- Square Online's lowest paid plan is Square Plus at $49 per location per month, as of October 23, 2026.
- Both work with Afterpay, Instagram and Facebook.
- Big Cartel has a public API. We haven't confirmed one for Square Online.
From each tool's own website, checked on the dates below, and from published reviews.
Which to choose
From the facts checked for both tools, not from opinion. A fact we haven't confirmed for one of them is never counted.
Choose Square Online if you need
No checked fact sets Square Online apart from Big Cartel yet.
Big Cartel
Nobody has reviewed Big Cartel yet. Its rating shows once it has 3 reviews.
Review Big Cartel
Square Online
Nobody has reviewed Square Online yet. Its rating shows once it has 3 reviews.
Review Square OnlineThe facts
- What it does
- Big CartelSet up an online store and start selling fast
- Square OnlineBuild a free online store that sells itself
- Free plan
- Big CartelYes
- Square OnlineYes
- Pricing
- Big CartelNot confirmed
- Square OnlinePer location, monthly
- Paid plans from
- Big Cartel
What they share
From the platforms and integrations each website lists.
Integrations
Both
- Afterpay
Only Big Cartel
- PayPal
- Google Shopping
- Zapier
- Printify
- Omnisend
- Etsy
Only Square Online
People who switched
Reviewers who say they used one of these before the other.
No reviewer has said they moved between Big Cartel and Square Online yet.
Used either of them?
Your review makes this comparison better for the next person. Review Big Cartel or review Square Online.